SERMON: “Biblical Men & Women in the Church, Part 1,” (1 Cor. 11:2)
“Biblical Men and Women in the Church, Part 1”
(1 Cor. 11:2)
Series: “1 Cor: Holiness from Messes” #40 Text: 1
Corinthians 11:2
By: Shaun Marksbury Date: Nov. 1, 2026
Venue: Living Water Baptist Church Occasion: AM Service
Introduction
We live in a day of deep confusion about every aspect of who
we are as individuals and our roles with one another. There are people who wonder if their gender
matches the sex into which they are born, perhaps seeing terms like male and
female as too restrictive. There are
others who see men and women as equals in every way, meaning that any sense of
distinction between the sexes for the purposes of intrinsic hierarchy is likewise
too restrictive.
On the other hand, Christians who see this can
overcorrect. They might look at some
biblical principles and over-apply them.
They can begin to add some extrabiblical commands and legalistic
standards to the lives of men and women in the church.
This passage can help us sort through that. It begins a larger section that extends
through chapter 14, addressing disorders in corporate worship. Christian freedom in the church is being
exercised without regard for the glory of God or the good of others,[1]
and that’s creating divisions.[2] This includes dealing with mistakes about
spiritual gifts, the abuse of the Lord’s Supper, and the question of head
coverings.
That last item is the specific issue in 11:2–16. The question of head coverings concerns the
roles of men and women in public worship. This isn’t a minor cultural footnote in
history, as it’s part of Paul’s concern for ordered, God-glorifying assembly. Yet, to understand what head coverings are,
and whether women should wear them in our services today, we will have to study
the culture of Scripture as well as present-day culture.
This isn’t something I want to do in one sermon, as that
would force me to flatten a lot of information.
This is a dense passage, and it is a confusing topic for Christians
today.
For instance, what does v. 3 imply not just about the men
and women, but also about the Trinity?
There are also questions as to what the word “head” means throughout the
passage, the kind of head covering is required, the image of God in women in v.
7, the meaning of “authority” in v. 10, and what Paul means by “because of the
angels” in that verse.[3] Some also wonder what the passage directs us
to believe about hair length in vv. 14–15.
With all those questions and more, this sermon will only introduce us to
the passage, and then we’ll spend a couple more Sundays together working
carefully through it.
This morning, Paul begins the
passage not with correction, but with commendation. He praises them for what they were getting
right. If we want to get this subject
right, then we need to understand what he says in this verse as well as what
culture is like today.
First, Consider Why Paul’s Praise is Important
Now I praise you
because you remember me in everything and hold firmly to the traditions, just
as I delivered them to you.
Paul's praise is as intentional as it prepares them for his correction to come. He will later
withhold praise (vv. 17, 22), so these words are significant. This is his pastoral wisdom in practice: he
does not treat the Corinthians as total failures.
He praises them because they remember him in everything and they
“hold firmly to the traditions,” just as he delivered them. Simply stated, traditions are just those
things which are passed orally from one person to another.[4] Some opine that one tradition was the
Christian practice of head coverings — it’s something not commanded of women in
the OT. That then opens the question as
to whether extrabiblical traditions carry authority in the life of the
Christian.
However, that’s not how Scripture presents tradition for
believers. First, Paul explicitly warned
against being taken “captive through philosophy and empty deception, according
to the tradition of men” (Col. 2:6–8).
Moreover, Jesus condemned the Pharisees for transgressing God’s
commandments for the sake of their traditions, thereby invalidating God’s word
(Matt. 15:1–9).
The apostolic traditions Paul defended were rooted in
Christ’s authority and apostolic witness, not human invention. The traditions the Apostle Paul taught included
Jesus’s direct words and the narrative of His life, bringing out both Old
Testament prophecy and its connection in this chapter to the Lord’s Supper.
It is true that the language is that of authoritative
transmission. Paul is using the standard
Jewish and early Christian vocabulary for receiving and passing on teaching
(cf. 11:23; 15:1–3; 2 Thess 2:15; 3:6). This demonstrates that early Christians
adopted Jewish methods for preserving authoritative teaching.[5] These are not optional customs or human
inventions — they were the continuation of the word of God in their lives.
So, we should hold on to the plain meaning of Scripture, not
altering it. Too many today do not read
God’s words “just as I delivered them to you.”
We’ll talk more about that in a few minutes. There is an implicit call here to receive and
retain the teaching as it was given, not to reshape it.
The Corinthian church was orthodox in its confession. However, the next verse begins with the word
“but” because the Corinthians had misapplied it. They were disordered in lifestyle and worship,[6]
and that included the women. Even that
can be offensive to note today, but where women are sinning in ways that are
unique to them, they should be corrected just as the men need to be.
Specifically, they were struggling with how the Christian
life is lived out as men and women. Just
like today, it seems like some struggled with the implications of Galatians
3:28, that there is “neither male nor female.”
That text is talking about our equality before Christ in redemption, but
somewhere overapplying it, thinking that social conventions such as
distinctively male and female clothing were now unimportant.
The key piece of clothing that distinguished men and women,
especially those who were married, were head coverings.
Paul’s praise was important.
It establishes a gentle tone before his rebuke. But, it also reminds them of what they should
believe. They should use the word of God
as their guide to navigate where they should apply aspects of their culture and
avoid other aspects.
Similarly, we must do the same, but we need to see how
different our culture is:
Second, Consider Our Culture’s Need for Scripture’s Traditions
Our broader cultural current that treats sex-based
distinctions as outdated or oppressive.
As such, it seeks to flatten them, not just in the marketplace, but also
in the home and in the church. Some of
this began with a well-meaning effort to see women’s rights elevated, but
modern feminism has been driven by socialistic ideas and Marxism and has gone
through at least four stages of development.
For those interested in more, Darrel Harrison and Virgil
Walker recently recorded a three-hour episode to their Just Thinking podcast on
the topic. Episode #140 is simply called
“Feminism,”[7]
and it details the names and movements which are essential to know. I will attempt to distill their information
into just a few minutes with some brief notes.
The Invention of Feminism
- Charles
Fourier (French utopian socialist, 1772–1837) is commonly identified as
the man who coined/invented the term féminisme (1837).
- Advocated
communal living units, free love, the abolition or radical redefinition of
traditional marriage and family, and the idea that social progress is
measured by the degree of women’s “liberty.”
- Feminism
is “just another tentacle of Critical Theory,” structured with the social
binary of oppressor/oppressed, hegemonic power, lived experience as
epistemic authority, and “social justice” as the goal of overturning
norms.
- This
is why the politics of today seemed so tied to a question that disguises
itself as just a concern for equal treatment.
First Wave Feminism (roughly 1848–1920)
- Focused
primarily on legal and political equality, especially the right to vote
and property rights for married women.
- Key
moment: the Seneca Falls Convention (1848) and the Declaration of
Sentiments.
- Culminated
in the 19th Amendment (1920), granting women the right to vote.
- Largely
framed within existing social structures; many early leaders were also
involved in abolition and temperance.
Second Wave Feminism (roughly 1960s–1980s)
- Broadened
the agenda beyond voting rights to workplace equality, education,
reproductive rights which included contraception and abortion, sexuality,
and the critique of traditional domestic roles, pushing for no-fault
divorce.
- Landmark
text: Betty Friedan’s The Feminine Mystique (1963), which described
the apparent dissatisfaction of middle-class housewives.
- Major
developments included the founding of the National Organization for Women
(NOW), the push for the Equal Rights Amendment, and the 1973 Roe v.
Wade decision.
- Explicitly
challenged cultural assumptions about sex-based roles in the home, church,
and society. This wave is the main source of modern egalitarian pressure
on texts like 1 Corinthians 11.
Third Wave Feminism (roughly 1990s–early 2010s)
- Emphasized
diversity, individual choice, and “intersectionality” (the idea that
gender overlaps with race, class, etc.).
- Reacted
against what some saw as the second wave’s focus on white, middle-class
women.
- More
postmodern in tone: less interest in a single definition of womanhood and
more openness to fluid or personal expressions of gender.
- Influenced
by cultural shifts in media, education, and identity politics.
Fourth Wave Feminism (roughly mid-2010s–present)
- Characterized
by digital activism, social media campaigns (most notably #MeToo), and
continued focus on sexual harassment, power dynamics, and systemic claims.
- Further
intensifies identity-based frameworks and often treats biological sex
distinctions themselves as oppressive or outdated.
- Deeply
shapes contemporary cultural assumptions that many people bring to the
Bible, including the idea that any lasting difference in roles between men
and women is inherently unjust.
Darrell Harrison then noted that
he believed we are experiencing a distinct “fifth wave.” He sees an intensification of the
gender-identity trajectory already present in later third- and fourth-wave
thought, with biological sex treated as optional or oppressive, further
decoupling of “woman” from female embodiment.
Moreover, he noted the rise in “spiritual feminism” that involves
spiritual or pagan elements from nature/Mother Earth, with one feminist
describing it as an “ABC” religion: “Anything But Christianity.”
Feminism began as a movement for certain legal rights and
has developed, especially from the second wave onward, into a broader cultural
project that increasingly questions or rejects permanent, sex-based
distinctions in the home, church, and society. That trajectory is the main cultural obstacle
many people face when they open 1 Corinthians 11. The text’s teaching on headship and created
order stands in tension with the assumptions that have become common since the
1960s.
Now, the church stands in stark contrast to culture today,
just as it always has. It can correctly note
that hierarchy isn’t a sin, either in the home and church. Even so, it can be misunderstood and
misapplied in other ways. That leads us
to the next point.
Third, Consider When Church Overcorrects the Traditions
The church sees this problem with culture and tries to lead
the way in a different direction. That
good drive can lead us down some wrong paths.
For instance, there are some who seek to compromise, adopting egalitarian
or “evangelical feminist” approaches.
These reject complementarianism (male leadership in home and church) in
favor of mutual submission or functional equality in all roles. They may have women pastors, etc.
Other churches may ignore the issues. Megan Basham…
One way some churches do this is by asking women to get back
to wearing head coverings, and there is a whole movement that is trying to get
Christians to do just that. There is a
strong positive case to be made for this, and I want to save that discussion
for a future sermon. I wouldn’t call
that an overcorrection, although there can be legalistic applications of that.
The temptation, especially in conservative churches, to
over-correct with systems the text does not teach. One example of that comes from Bill Gothard
and his “Basic Life Principles” program.
He illustrates the “umbrella of authority,” which shows a hierarchy of Christ
as the large top umbrella, the husband beneath it with the roles “protect
family” and “provide for family” noted, and the wife under that umbrella as a manager
of home and children. If you read v. 3
in the text here, you may be tempted to think Gothard had the right idea.
However, the Bible doesn’t teach that the wife’s access to
Christ is mediated or filtered through her husband. Every believer has direct access to the Father
through Christ (1 Tim. 2:5; Eph. 2:18), and that is what is known as the
priesthood of all believers. The wife is
a co-heir (1 Pet. 3:7), and her spiritual standing and relationship to Christ
do not depend on remaining under her husband’s umbrella. Incidentally, Gothard’s entire system is
dangerous, taking Scripture to legalistic extremes, and he himself is facing
scandal.
Still, some outside the formal Gothard movement have adopted
similar “chain of command” or covering language. These often treat male authority more broadly
or absolutely than Scripture does, and they can functionally place the husband
between the wife and Christ or make submission a condition of spiritual safety.
They may believe that women are
inherently more gullible because Eve was deceived, and they may say things like
women shouldn’t work outside the home, go to college, or live without men.
These are all extrabiblical distortions of the truth. We can affirm ordered roles grounded in
creation (as 1 Corinthians 11 does) while rejecting both egalitarianism and
these more authoritarian systems. Headship
is servant leadership patterned on Christ, not a protective umbrella that
subordinates the wife’s direct relationship to the Lord.
We will examine the headship principle, the cultural
practice, the difficult reference to the angels, the mutual interdependence,
and the application to men and women in marriage and in the church. Throughout, the controlling question remains
the one Paul raises here: Are we holding firmly to the traditions just as they
were delivered?
Conclusion
Next week, we’ll turn to the content of those traditions as
Paul unfolds them, beginning with the headship statement in verse 3.
As a church, though, we must remember what we have been
taught in Scripture and hold firmly to it, just as God preserved it here for
us. Let’s not give into either cultural
accommodation a temptation to add to the text. Rather, it’s to remember and hold what the
apostles delivered.
That’s the standard by which we will read the rest of the
passage. It’s the standard that will
keep us from both the egalitarian flattening of the text and the authoritarian
over-application of it. We must hold to
the truth of the word, not adding to it or taking away from it.
[1] David K. Lowery, The
Bible Knowledge Commentary: An Exposition of the Scriptures, 1985, 2, 528.
[2] J. I. Packer, Wayne Grudem, and Ajith Fernando, Eds.,
ESV Global Study
Bible, (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2012), 1618.
[3] Roy E. Ciampa and Brian S. Rosner, The First Letter to
the Corinthians, The Pillar New Testament Commentary (Grand
Rapids, MI; Cambridge, U.K.: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2010),
503.
[4] John D. Barry, Douglas Mangum, Derek R. Brown,
Michael S. Heiser, Miles Custis, Elliot Ritzema, Matthew M. Whitehead, Michael
R. Grigoni, and David Bomar, Faithlife Study
Bible, (Bellingham, WA: Lexham Press, 2012, 2016), 1 Co 11:2.
[5] R. Riesner, “Tradition,” in New dictionary of biblical theology, eds. T. Desmond Alexander and
Brian S. Rosner, (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2000), 825.
[6] John F. MacArthur Jr., 1 Corinthians,
MacArthur New Testament Commentary (Chicago: Moody Press, 1984), 252.
[7] “EP# 140 | Feminism,” https://justthinking.me/140-2/.